Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 16th November 2008 Change Date

Free Gerhard Richter Print

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

War hero to blitz the honours system



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 31 August 2008
HIS astonishing act of wartime bravery saw him being honoured by the King and lauded as a hero by his fellow Glaswegians.

Now, more than 60 years later, Archibald Walker's selfless act of courage during the dark days of the Clydebank blitz could lead to a major change in Britain's honours system.

Walker, a Glasgow police officer, was among hundreds who were on duty
on the nights of March 13 and 14, 1941, when the Luftwaffe carried out a devastating attack on the Clydeside area, flattening 4,000 homes and killing 528 people.

With no thought for his own safety, Walker plunged into the inferno of one building, pulling out bodies and saving the lives of at least two people.

That summer he was given the George Medal, the award which had been instituted a year earlier by George VI to mark civilian acts of bravery during the London blitz.

The award was an immense source of pride to the Walker family, but over the years they began to question the medal.

Not only was the medal itself inscribed with an image of St George, an accompanying citation spoke of "all of us who love England".

Walker died 12 years ago at the age of 82. But his son Alistair has started a campaign to create a new 'St Andrew's Medal' specifically for Scots who have committed acts of bravery.

Scotland on Sunday can reveal that the SNP will take up Walker's case at the party's annual conference this autumn, when it will vote on creating a new medal for civilian Scots.

Leaked copies of the party's autumn conference agenda reveal that party members will decide this October whether "to award a St Andrew's medal for civilian acts of bravery to anyone deserving of such an award".

With the resolution certain to be backed, SNP ministers will then take the proposal forward.

Plans are still to be discussed on how the medal would be awarded. One option would be to create a separate award, bequeathed by the Holyrood administration and running alongside the existing honours structure. The other, which would need the co-operation of Westminster, would see the George Medal and Cross replaced by the St Andrew's honour.

But last night, Labour MSPs hit back warning that such measures amounted to "independence by stealth", insisting that the George Cross and George Medal were UK-wide honours which should remain in place.

Walker said last night that the English bias on his father's George Medal had long rankled with the family.

"Of course, my father was happy to have received the George Medal, but he would have preferred something Scottish," he said.

"He was very happy to go to Buckingham Palace. But now we have a devolved Scottish Government and maybe it is time for a St Andrew's Medal. It is right that the English should have their medal and the Scots should have theirs."

Walker said he thought that the Scottish Government should appoint a body to recommend recipients, before the monarch of the day came to Edinburgh to present it.

He added: "This isn't to do with independence or the SNP, it's to do with Scotland. I hope the SNP conference will now pass it."

Chris McLaughlin, of the SNP's Eastwood branch, which is putting forward the resolution said: "Both Alistair and his father, whilst very happy to have been decorated, felt that it should have been a Scottish medal.

"This will certainly be backed at conference and it will then become party policy. It will then be the responsibility of the SNP Government to make it happen. This would be a replacement medal. The George Medal and the George Cross are English medals."

However, Labour MSP Lord Foulkes urged caution over the proposal, saying it could feed into the SNP's wider strategy to gradually loosen ties within the UK.

Foulkes said: "What the SNP want to do, and it is very clever, is bit by bit, they are trying to make people more willing to accept things that are Scottish only, rather than Scottish and British. It is separation by stealth. All this is a cleverly worked out strategy to try to move things in the direction whereby each step of itself is not much, but when it adds up, it is quite a lot." He added: "It should be stressed that the George Cross is named after a Sovereign not a Saint."

The idea of a St Andrew's medal was first raised earlier this year by SNP MSP Christine Grahame.

Grahame said: "The British George Medal depicts Saint George of England slaying a mythical dragon, a representation that remains quintessentially English. There is nothing wrong with that of course, but clearly the Scottish Government will, I am sure, be keen to commission an award that reflects Scotland's own national character in a manner that is more fitting for those who receive the medal."

Notable recipients of the George Medal include navy frogman Lionel 'Buster' Crabb, racing driver Mike Hailwood, nursery nurse Lisa Potts, Everest climber Tenzing Norgay and Nancy Wake, known to the Gestapo as "the White Mouse" because of her skills at evading capture when she worked with the French resistance.

The most recent recipient of the higher ranking George Cross, for civilians or service personnel, was Lance Corporal Matt Croucher, from Birmingham, who was awarded the George Cross last month after he dived on a Taliban grenade in order to save his fellow soldiers.

Another recent recipient was Corporal Mark Wright, of the 3rd Battalion, the Parachute Regiment, who died in Helmand Province, Afghanistan, in September 2006 after entering a minefield in a bid to save the lives of other injured soldiers.





The full article contains 955 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 30 August 2008 9:47 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
 
1

Canada,

Canada 31/08/2008 01:19:16
Time to grow up Scotland. As possibly the oldest nation in Europe proclaim your unique identity.
2

Guga II,

Rockall 31/08/2008 02:05:00
The George Cross, with its depiction of the English St. George, and the "all of us who love England" bit is a relic of colonialism. It is long past time that we had a medal of similar status for Scotland.

As for Lard George, don't worry about it mate, there is no chance they'll be awarding you one, not even your beloved English one.
3

Scotindy,

Los Angeles 31/08/2008 02:52:52
This guy foulkes is a DISGRACE TO SCOTLAND AND HER PEOPLE. He should stay in london with his other colonial cronies, and please do not come back. It is scum like him who have kept SCOTLAND BACK. NO MORE SCOTLAND WILL BE INDEPENDENT IN 2009.
4

The Daleks,

Longmen 31/08/2008 06:23:27
Foulkes said: "What the SNP want to do, and it is very clever, is bit by bit, they are trying to make people more willing to accept things that are Scottish only, rather than Scottish and British.

Foulkes really hasn't got a clue, has he? There have always been things which are specifically Scottish, rather than British.

What about SCE Highers, for example?

The list is long. But you get the gist.
5

james 1st,

hamilton nz 31/08/2008 06:57:17
seems to me that np scot should be presented with a medal that says "all of those who love england "
the medal does show arrogance and a lack of respect sor the scots. surely if the medal is for all britons another design would have been more appropriate'
the snp should support any change, it would do scottish labour much more good than harm to insist on a change
continuation of a single medal designed as at present can only harm the union'
all scots shouls be disgusted
6

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 31/08/2008 08:39:55
When my Scottish grandfather died fighting for BRITAIN alongside English, Welsh and Irish comrades, seconded as he was at the time to an 'English' regiment, I'm sure the last thing on his mind was whether the crown on his cap page was an English or Scottish one or what form any medal he may have got would have. I'm sure the first thing on my grandmother's mind was to be incensed that the mass-produced citation of thanks from King George VI was headed with the English version of the royal arms. So many of you are so feckin' PETTY, it makes my blood boil and, God help me, squirm to be a Scot sometimes.
7

gus1940,

Edinburgh 31/08/2008 08:50:32
Hardline unionists put on the back foot again and more drivel from Foulkes.
8

Andanotherthing,

31/08/2008 09:04:06
I agree with *5. Change the design of the current Medal which is a UK-wide honour and should remain in place. The award was instituted by George VI, hence the name. Looks like SNP want to set up a new Scottish medals Committee and more jobs for the boys.
9

Mikey,

31/08/2008 09:20:01
So, Scots should receive medals, not for serving Scotland or even the UK, but for loving England? Hmmm, tends to point to EXACTLY where the onionists are coming from, doesn't it?

These people really get on my nerves! These onionists are stupid enough to allow themselves to be brainwashed by Westmonster and then come on here to abuse people who are intelligent enough to think for themselves!

The lunatics have been running the asylum since 1707!
10

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 31/08/2008 09:35:49
#9 Mikey

Read the rticle before opening your gob. Yes, the CITATION was awful but it was of its time, I would hop it wouldn't even be thought of now. The medal was and remains a medal given to brave people from all the countries of the UK. It's called the George Medal after the king who instituted it, not the saint on it. And the saint on it is Saint George, not because he happens to be patron sent of England but because he's traditionally represented slaying a dragon, which is SYMBOLIC of the triumph of good over evil. Remember the wee conflict that was going on at the time? You Nats need to engage brain before getting all embarrassingly chippy.
11

Mr. Lachie Todd,

Edinburgh 31/08/2008 09:56:22
Many will be surprised that the George Cross (and Medal) is enscribed with the words: "all of us who love England"?

However, according to the authoritive memoirs of Scot, Lord Home of the Hirsel: "It was always generally accepted by the Scottish people that, at the height of the British Empire, and during the dark days of the Second World War, the cumbersome state title United Kingdom or Great Britain, was always referred to as England".

Well, Lord Home, as a former Foreign Secretary and Prime Minister should know! Lord Home was Neville Chamberlain's PPS and accompanied him to Munich for the "Peace in our Time" talks with Hitler "to settle for once and all the argument between Germany and England"?

12

bill-alba,

fife 31/08/2008 10:04:42
draco..the medal is a medal of its time...when we were all closed minded unionists like you..if my just happen to have a dragon on it and the king was george..but cant you see if it has a dragon being slayed on it, it is Saint George and not king george who they are potraying..the medal is very appropriate for England but it is not approporiate for Scotland and yes I do remember the wee conflict going on at the time and did my family that conflict doesnt make it right to have a foreign countries saint issued to us...
You britnats need to get of your knees trying crouching for a wee bit then maybe try standing up straight for once you are embarrassingly cringing down there.
13

Guga II,

Rockall 31/08/2008 10:12:37
#6 Draco the Wimp.

Just as well you're an ex-plod, otherwise I'm sure you'd have us all arrested for being nasty to your precious Engerland.

14

Albaexpat,

Masterton 31/08/2008 10:26:00
I wonder what the reaction of the Maltese people was ,when their island was presented with the George Cross.
15

james 1st,

hamilton nz 31/08/2008 10:46:18
^draco the wimp my parents were around during the little conflict you mention and did endure the clydebank blitz, one of my grandmothers lost her house as did a couple of my aunts, i dont think they would have approved of the wording "all of those who love england". just admit that there should have been a different design and different wording, theres a good chap. times have certainly now changed and the medal is archaic and demeaning, either change it or have a different medal for scots, the snp will be correct to support a change and scottish labour will only confirm that they have no appetite for supporting scotland if the dont support the move,
all parties that sit at hollyrood should have their head office in scotland and should have to go to a party domicliled in england for permission to have a political view
16

Ribbonman,

Glasgow (east) 31/08/2008 11:15:20
There is absolutely no sense in having a "Scottish" medal,whilst we are still under English rule.I think that the medal held by the late Mr. Walker really sums up our position then and now. English men and women with Scottish accents I would call it!
17

shivago8,

livingston 31/08/2008 11:17:02
Lets run Foulkes out of this country,he is evil and should have the Scottish blood taken out of his veins.
Dont see anything wrong about being Scottish,for gods sake are we not sitting in Scottish soil.
18

Ribbonman,

Glasgow (east) Very much Scottish and proud too! 31/08/2008 11:19:29
#11 In all my travells throughout the world I have seldom heard Scotland being referred to as "Scotland". The name given to our country is more than often, England,and can you really blame foreigners for thinking thus?
19

Ribbonman,

31/08/2008 11:25:33
#17 Toally agree. Wait! I will be back with the rope.
20

Ribbonman,

31/08/2008 11:26:45
#19 That toally was Glesga talk for "totally"
21

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 31/08/2008 12:16:30
It seems the Scottish education system isn't as good as we like to kid ourselves. It seems most of you haven't even basic reading skills.

And #13 Gaga,

I'm sure it won't be long before your pathetic, twisted racism ends you up in court. You're a disgrace to Scotland and thankfully the vast majority of Scots would recogmise you for the sad wee man you are.

22

Budgie,

Renfrew 31/08/2008 13:16:19
Draco Was a Wimp.
Have to laugh at your posting No.21.
As classic case of "the pot calling the kettle black" as ever there was.!
Accept that the Citation accompanying Mr. Walkers' honour IS insulting to a Scottish recipient - whose heroic act was rendered in Scotland - and recognise that the reference to England is entirely out of place.
It would have been appropriate if the head of the Monarch was portrayed, rather than the Patron Saint of England - or any other Saint.
23

Draco Was a Wimp,

31/08/2008 16:39:57
#22 Budgie

Another one that cannae read. I refer you to my post at #10 on both points.
24

Guga II,

Rockall 31/08/2008 17:15:36
#21 Draco the Wimp.

Unfortunately for you Mr. Ex-plod, I am not a racist, and there is no law that says I can't object to having foreigners impose their colonial rule on my country.

As for being a "sad wee man", I am far from being sad, and at six feet in my stocking soles, I am not wee. I'd be even taller if I had on size 13 plod boots though.

Regarding being a disgrace to Scotland, I would have thought that it was cretins such as yourself that were a disgrace to Scotland. Get up off your knees, and stop kow-towing to foreigners.
25

Murray in Canada,

Salt Spring Island 31/08/2008 18:05:53
Okay, but can someone supply a citation of the citation?

As for a new medal. it's a great idea. Perhaps one could have a short leet of recipients, and the final one could be chosen by the sovereign him/herself. Isn't that a radical idea? I've always thought that the fiction of the sovereign decorating someone chosen by the PM of the day was ridiculous.
26

Draco Was a Wimp,

Edinburgh 31/08/2008 18:23:30
#24 Gaga

Thankfully, like most of my fellow countrymen, my pride in being a Scot doesn't need to be measured in terms of how much I feel the need to dislike my neighbours. Shouting about how much of a Scot you are just makes your insecurity and inferiority complex all the more apparent. You and your ilk shame us all and the sooner the SNP roots you out the better.
27

Guga II,

Rockall 31/08/2008 18:32:50
#26 Draco the Wimp.

Still can't get up off your knees then?
28

Robbierunciman,

Romney Marsh 31/08/2008 19:06:47
I think the solution is to change 'England' to 'Britain'.

I often read about 'hardlibe or 'raving' unionists from a few writers on this website. Perhaps the writers, mostly right whingers - who appear to be SNP simpathizers ought to realize that there is raving and it si not the unionists doing it.
29

Exiled Tweedsider,

salisbury 01/09/2008 09:14:41
14 - probably great pride, which it is why it is on their flag, and in the full title of the country!
30

John1,

Stirling 01/09/2008 11:26:40
I get as irritated as anyone when those from the deep south use "England" as a synonym for "The United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland" "The UK" is becoming used more as an acceptable abbreviation. The problem is persuading the London-centrics that most of the country lies north of Watford. I would not be happy with a "Scotland-only" medal, which strikes me as just another attempt by the SNP to push us into separation by the back door. In WW2 it was the UK and the preservation of civilisation that everyone was fighting for, not Scotland alone. The George medal, and any others with the same problem, should be altered accordingly.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.