Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Sunday, 31st August 2008 Change Date

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Scotland On Sunday site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Ordeal of Scots who missed the Dunkirk boats



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 18 May 2008
IT WAS a defining moment of the Second World War in which 200,000 British troops were rescued from certain death or capture after being defeated by the Germans in France.
And now, the amazing story has emerged of a Scottish soldier who escaped, was recaptured and narrowly avoided execution by the SS after the intervention of a regular German Army officer.

David Mowatt, from the Black Isle, was one of thousands of t
roops taken prisoner by the Germans in the northern French town of St Valery after they failed to make it to the Allied evacuation on the beaches of Dunkirk.

Mowatt's tale is to be told in a new book to be published next month called Dunkirk: The Men They Left Behind, by the leading historical writer Sean Longden.

Amid the euphoria over saving the troops from disaster, few focused on the thousands of soldiers left behind who had fought alongside the French Army and on the later evacuations of soldiers from other parts of the French coast.

In June 1940, the 51st Highland Division was surrounded at St Valery en Caux and forced to surrender.

For Mowatt, captivity came as a severe shock. Two years before the outbreak of the Second World War, he joined the local Territorial Army battalion in search of extra cash and a welcome break from his job as a farm labourer.

He said: "We thought we'd join the TA and get a holiday."

As part of the Fourth Battalion the Seaforth Highlanders, he was stationed in northern France, where he and colleagues would sneak out into no man's land looking for signs of whether the Germans were moving forward.

He lost a close friend in battle and his division was pushed back across France by the relentless German advance before the division was captured at St Valery. They had hoped to get to Le Havre, where another evacuation was under way. Mowatt himself personally encountered the Nazis' star commander, General Erwin Rommel.

Mowatt said: "Rommel came up, he was on one of the first tanks to come through. He spoke to us. He said: 'I hope you will be treated fairly and you will not be too long a prisoner of war.' He was right there at the front with his troops. He probably knew we'd had it. He knew he was safe."

Mowatt found that he was one of 40,000 British soldiers marched towards Germany with little food, water or rest. He completely wore out a brand-new pair of double-soled boots during the forced march to Dortmund.

Speaking of the horror of that march, he said: "I didn't have the strength to talk. We were all dragged right down. We were filthy – lousy. I can't describe the despair. It was terrible. The days just blurred into each other. We didn't know how far we were going to march – we were just going in circles."

He and his comrades endured brutality from German guards who shot soldiers who reached out for food which French peasants had put by the roadside for them. And then in the camps they had to endure more trauma from fellow British soldiers as officers and NCOs tried to impose discipline on the exhausted and demoralised prisoners.

Mowatt said: "I can't remember entering the camp. All I can remember was a Welsh Sergeant Major. He was trying to get us to march up and down – after all the way we'd walked! I collapsed and ended up in hospital.

"That sergeant eventually wangled his way on to a repatriation ship. On the boat on the way home he vanished. Someone got him and dumped him over the side. It was someone who remembered him from the camp, and thought, 'I'll have him one day!'"

Mowatt then spent almost five years in the Thorn PoW camp in occupied Poland until the chance came for freedom in 1945.

As the Red Army advanced through Poland and East Prussia, the Germans set about evacuating the camps and marching the prisoners west.

Mowatt and three others men managed to escape and headed east towards the advancing Soviet troops. They survived in the Polish countryside for two weeks by killing and eating farm animals. But they were then captured by the SS, who planned to shoot the fugitive PoWs. They were only saved when an ordinary German officer appeared and took the five men into his care.

He said: "One morning we woke up to the sound of tanks. We thought: 'Good God, we're at the front line.' By the time we got dressed all the doors had been smashed in. We were expecting it to be the Russians, but it was the SS. They put us up against the wall with a firing squad of five men. It's dreadful to think about it even now.

"Then an ordinary Wehrmacht officer appeared. Lady Luck was on our side. He stopped them."

Mowatt and his comrades were finally liberated after the Germans surrendered in May 1945.

As Mowatt suffered in captivity, the Highland Division was rebuilt with the single brigade that had escaped from France and with fresh recruits.

They played a key role in breaking the German lines at El Alamein. They then fought in Italy and Normandy, and in 1944, British commander Field Marshal Montgomery changed his order of battle in northern France to allow the 51st to liberate Saint-Valery.

Dunkirk: The Men They Left Behind by Sean Longden is published by Constable and will cost £20 in hardback. It will be published on May 29.



The full article contains 938 words and appears in Scotland On Sunday newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 17 May 2008 7:31 PM
  • Source: Scotland On Sunday
  • Location: Scotland
  • Related Topics: World War II
 
1

Conan the Librarian™,

18/05/2008 01:22:47
http://www.sauldavid.co.uk/popups/churchill.htm
2

Mikey,

18/05/2008 04:44:18
My grandfather was in the Gordons and captured at St Valery. He spent 5 years in Stalag VIIIB in Lamsdorf, betrayed by Churchill who thought it 'not wise' to have a Guards batallion fighting a rearguard action!

While the Guards ran, the Scots and some English yokel batallions were left to cover the retreat. Once again, the Scots were expendable and STILL some people vote for England!
3

Lanna,

18/05/2008 04:54:11
sounds like a good read.
4

Gordon Angus,

Sydney not the Australian One. 18/05/2008 05:06:30
It is well documented that the then Lt General Rommel arrived at St Valery en Caux by staff car not on a tank, equally well recorded he never spoke to British troops, only to Maj General Victor Fortune through an interpreter.
Double-soled boots were only ever issued for soldiers performing Public Duties in London, NEVER to any other soldiers, the history of "The Pattern Room" in 2003 makes that quite clear.
There was a series of articles in the late 1940's in the "Journal of the Royal Army Medical Corps" dealing with the repatriation of the sick and chronically wounded from German PoW camps-the amputees,blind, mad (some of whom were not but successfully pretended to be), suffering from cancer etc. Everyone that got onto the various Swedish ships, got off them in British ports, so the sergeant major story is utter rhubarb!!!
The contemptuous remark about the Foot Guards is not worth a comment.
My wifes uncle was captured at Dunkirk, and was a Dentist at Stalag XXB, Willenberg on and off during the war, the British Man of Confidence was Company Sergeant Major James Fulton, 2nd Seaforths. His opinion being that the British Army Regular NCOs and Warrant Officers were the backbone of the camps, and due to their efforts men survived with their health, dignity and self respect.
Yours,
G/.
5

JESSE,

UK 18/05/2008 07:10:55
Bravo for you Mr. Angus (#4)

The truth is a difficult thing to come by with soldiers in all wars who write and speak about things that they claim to be involved in.

I have observed that most men who have seen real combat in the front lines feel little need to talk about their activities and most certainly refraim from spreading lies.

I am sure David Mowatt did not have an easy time of it as a POW. He implies that all German Stalags were death camps which is certainly not true

He speaks of fighting with the French--unfortunately the French (a long time enemy of England) did little to fight against the Germans.They French had one of the largest armies in all of Europe!

The German army had huge numbers of volunteers from most major countries-- many, many, thousands came from Russia.Worse yet, many Frenchmen volunteered to fight with the German Wehrmacht.

It is also true that many soldiers never saw any combat in a particular battle because they were either held in reserve or performed non combative support roles.

To say he was personally adressed by Rommel is absolute nonsense--the chance of an enlisted man getting within one mile of any general is next to impossible.

People love lies and create terrible myths.

Perhaps this and the Hollywod approach to war is what makes war so ramantic and popular!

Lest we forget--war is about humanitarian reasons and never about OIL!
6

big big fun,

18/05/2008 08:20:34
why has the scotsman stopped anyone from commenting on the sports section ?
7

Nebulous,

Aberdeen 18/05/2008 08:30:20
I'm quite disgusted by the comments at #4 and #5.

Here we have an elderly man telling the story of what he did for his country - how he gave 5 years of his life and suffered in a concentration camp. And all you can care about is whether he had double-soled boots or not!

I've made my mind up to buy it - and no I'm not looking for historical accuracy in every detail- I'm looking for some of the human story behind the history. You would do well to remember what such people did for us rather than what Rommel drove.
8

Cludgie,

18/05/2008 08:54:15
Scots left behind to defend the British Army's rear... No !!! It could never happen, surely not. Scots cannonfodder? I don't believe it. That would never happen now. Scots would not be sent to the most dangerous places on the planet whilst their Southern British counterparts larged it up in Crete? !! That would never happen now !! (the noise is the sound of tongue grinding on inside cheek)
9

Navvy,

18/05/2008 09:00:36
#4 & 5

What you write rings true.
My faterh was a regular soldier from 1937, Palestine where he won the MC, against teh japanese, greek civil war, berlin around the airlift, korea, malaysia

He seldom talked about it and then mostly to contempories and evesdroppers on those conversations. Memory is selective and few soldiers have much idea of the larger picture, how could they. We are lucky in that we have some contemporary writings by my father and some wonderful sketches - a book perhaps one day
10

Fairfax,

18/05/2008 09:26:44
Cludgie (8): "Scots cannonfodder? I don't believe it."

Instead of Scottish solipsism, you could read "Dunkirk: Fight To The Last Man", by Simon Sebag-Montefiore.
11

Upbeat,

18/05/2008 13:26:18
What is a surprise is that so few of you proud scots here today appear to have known anything about the glorious rearguard action fought by the 51st Highland Division, which ended in the St Valery surrender. An earlier ighaldn didvision was decomated in the battle for Loos in the Ist world war. The parallels are uncanny. Most of those Highlanders captured in 1940 did survive the war. Their father's generation kill;ed in action did not.

The story is a very complex one, involving the political desire to support the French defence of Paris, the need to divert Blitzkreig troops that might otherwise have been free to impose even greater pressure on the Dunkirk bridgehead. There is also the truth that Royal Navy ships werre not authorised to come close in under the cliffs at St Valery...St Valery was a port singularly unsuited to mass evecaution anyway. It was too small and shallow...the barges and small boats required for evacuation were not available. Meanwhile Le Havre, the alternate port of embarkation was cpatured by the Germans in a left hook operation through weak and ineffective French forces which left the 51st surrounded.

The idea that Prisonners of war were incarcerated in " Concentration camps" is a poor use of language. Dedicated POW camps were established across northern Europe.These operated for the most part under the terms and agreements of the Geneva convention ...although there were many breaches in practice. The modern understanding of the term " concentration camp" is something different. These immoral prisons had nothing to do with the Geneva convention , but were operated to contain displaced peoples, aliens , spies (those captured out of uniform )and those engaged in activities against the state of Germany.

Your local Scottish libaries have many books on the fate of the 1940 51st division at St Valery. But teh name did not " die" there. The revived 51st led the way at El Alamien on through Sicily , and into Italy .
12

Robbierunciman,

Romney Marsh 18/05/2008 13:32:40
I agree with 10 and have read the book - excellent!

I visited St valery a year or so back and was amazed to see a saltire fluttering on a flag pole in the main sqaure and a Granite monument on a hill above the town.
These troops were not willingly abandoned. The navy tried to get them (June 10 -11 1940- I think) but the Germans had advanced to positions overlooking the town. The British did get troops away a little further along the beach.

We need to look at the events how they unfolded at the time, not with hindsight and later propaganda. The modern view of Dunkirk sees it as a result, victroy from the jaws of defeat. At the time, things were much more comfused, it was not viewed as an end to our involvement in France - they were expected to offer more resistance.

The clue comes in the name of the rescue of troops from Dunkirk, it was called 'operation Dynamo'. The plan was drawn up by an overlooked war Hero Admiral Ramsey. After a few days, huge numbers of French troops were repatriated via Cherbourg.

The idea had been that they would reinforce the line - unfortunately their command structure had collapsed in the meantime and there was no line to reinforce. The plan had been to form a line to halt the German advance (on the river Somme) but it failed.

Before critisizing the french its worth reflecting that had we been invaded, would we have had quislings too - Churchill thought so - why did Hess Fly to Scotland, Hitler had many admirers in the upper echelons of British society? Halifax had been keen to secure a peace deal through Mussolini...

The petty nationalist comments above are a disgrace.
13

scottish person,

paisley 18/05/2008 14:06:31
The reason that not many know of the 51st fighting a rearguard action is due to the fact that in the BBC's world at war the rearguard action was not mentioned. The commentator said that the French put up a great fight on behalf of the escaping troops. Both Guy Ritchie and Hugh Grant's grand fathers were officers in the action. When Hugh Grant decided to make a film about it, his grandfather asked him not to.A sad day for churchill the coward. It is long overdue that the truth should come out about this man.
14

antifa,

18/05/2008 14:19:36
"While the Guards ran, the Scots and some English yokel batallions were left to cover the retreat."

So actually it has nothing to do with nationality then, does it?

On your own evidence the English regiments were also seen as "expendable".

Might be a class angle though - and Churchill was most definitely in politics to defend the interests of his class.
15

Upbeat,

18/05/2008 15:37:34
What relevance the BBC or Churchill have to do with this series of events is known only to those that are here to pontificate about something they have not bothered to read about or study for themselves.

The history of this retreat to the channel ports was well known at the time....with the marked exception of the Lancastria disaster which was officially covered up. Churchill had only just come into office on 10th May 1940, so was hardly responsible for the German advance or the French dissembling which l;ed directly to events surrounding St Valery resulting in the surrender on 12th June. General Fortune OC 51 st Highland division had units from the whole UK and commonwealth under command. The division has never comprised only an entirely Scottish background. Only two of the three brigades were forced to surrender at St Valery the 154th brigade escaped .

The "potted" history as recounted by BBC & Time Life etc documentary series are largely irrelevent . They were only a reflection in the sketchiest detail of a number historical events during the war, refined down to fill 26 episodes , the whole compiled several decades after the war ended.

Had anyone wanted to learn about St Valery...their local library would have educated them. The Official WW2 history of the 51 st Highland division was first published in the early 1950's, most Scottish libraries will still retain it in their catalogues...and it has since been republished. The many biographies of General Fortune and other commanders involved contain more valuable detail. This new book described here will add valuable personal testament and further detail to the picture, but the sequence of historical events will always remain as previously described.
16

response,

Syd 18/05/2008 15:42:37
Och looks like the Scotsman has started another war,bring out our Donald T and we will have a game o' golf, Yes someone is right my two uncle's were in France and North Africa and they would never talk about what they had gone through.
17

mr angry,

ayrshire 19/05/2008 08:37:49
#4 & #5 what a pair of creeps, hgow would you two dumplings know what this man went through and whether every waking minute of Rommells progress and type of transport was recorded. Couple of sad losers trying to make out that you clever and know everything, get a life you saddo's.
18

Dougie, Edinburgh,

19/05/2008 10:06:18
17 mr angry,ayrshire
Not interested in historical truth then?
19

Russell M,

Stirling 20/05/2008 22:34:01
Scots have been expendable in the eyes of the British nobility since the 13th Century. When an attitude or behaviour lasts for over 700 years (over 20 generations) I think it might be called Leitkultur. What surprises me the most is the English reluctance to finish us off. After all we only represent 10% of UK population, 1/3 of the number killed by the Black Death. Could it be that we have some worth to the UK after all?

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 

Today's Vote

Is the government right to continue with its policy of cutting down quangos?
No, I think their independence means we get a better job
Yes, they are unaccountable and expensive
Only if their work is duplicated or plainly redundant

Web Links:

Featured Advertising



Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.